Burroughs Adding Machine

Social justice, arts and politics, life in New York City

Gay Rights Don’t Need Biology

A female pair at a Laysan albatross colony in Kaena Point, Hawaii. (Lindsay C. Young)

The New York Times Magazine features an article teasingly headlined, “Can Animals Be Gay?” It’s a question central to many on both sides of the culture wars; and in revisiting the argument, the NYT has little new information to add. We’ve heard of the male penguins who raised a chick together in Germany, as well as Scientific American‘s list of animals who engage in same-sex behavior. What’s the new news?

Central to the NYT‘s premise is the research of biologist Lindsay C. Young, who has been studying a colony of albatross birds in Hawaii for decades. The albatross spends most of the year in solitude, but returns to the same spot in Kaena Point each November. Among Young’s surprising findings were:

Laysan albatrosses are one of countless species in which the two sexes look basically identical. It turned out that many of the female-female pairs, at Kaena Point and at a colony that Young’s colleague studied on Kauai, had been together for 4, 8 or even 19 years — as far back as the biologists’ data went, in some cases. The female-female pairs had been incubating eggs together, rearing chicks and just generally passing under everybody’s nose for what you might call “straight” couples.

Fairly interesting stuff. But Young herself wants to stay clear of the politics and focus on her scientific research.

“ ‘Lesbian,’ ” she told me, “is a human term,” and Young — a diligent and cautious scientist, just beginning to make a name in her field — is devoted to using the most aseptic language possible and resisting any tinge of anthropomorphism. “The study is about albatross,” she told me firmly. “The study is not about humans.” Often, she seemed to be mentally peer-reviewing her words before speaking.

So this seems a case of the author/NYT pursuing a reluctant scientist to weigh in on the culture wars. Is it fair to Young? To the fervent critics on both sides of the gay debate? One wants Young to come out and state whether she’s pro-gay or anti-gay, simply to bring her research out of the realm of clinical science into the more interesting arena of social attitudes.

In thinking about homosexuality, the question of nature versus nurture often comes to light. What seems more important to me, however, is not the “causes” but our attitudes about gays and lesbians (not to mention our often-forgotten transgendered and bisexual brothers and sisters). If we go about trying to prove our worth as LGBTQ Americans, we unspool a thread of endless argument. We’re not asking people to argue where our feelings and love for others comes from, but to accept and guarantee our rights to love whom we wish.

Science can’t afford the civil rights we seek. Seeking validity through this path seems like a dead end for LGBTQ advocates.

Advertisements

Filed under: biology, gay rights, , , , , ,

Publications

BIOGRAPHY

RECENT PUBLICATIONS
» "Pinays," AGNI, Spring 2016
» "Dandy," Post Road, Spring 2015
» "Wrestlers," Fifth Wednesday, Spring 2014
» "Babies," Joyland, August 2011
» "Nicolette and Maribel," BostonNow, May 2007
» "The Rice Bowl," Memorious, March 2005
» "The Rules of the Game," Screaming Monkeys: Critiques of Asian American Images (Coffee House Press, June 2003)
» "Deaf Mute," Growing Up Filipino (Philippine American Literary House, April 2003)
» "Good Men ," Genre, April 2003
» "The Foley Artist," Drunken Boat, April 2002
» "Squatters," Take Out: Queer Writing from Asian Pacific America (Asian Am. Writers' Workshop, 2001)
» "Deaf Mute," The North American Review, Jan 2001
» "The First Lady of Our Filipino Nation," The Boston Phoenix, 1999
» "Paper Route," Flyway Literary Review, 1996
» "Brainy Smurf and the Council Bluffs Pride Parade," Generation Q (Alyson, 1996)
June 2019
M T W T F S S
« Jul    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Twitter

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

Visitor Map

Locations of Site Visitors

RSS Recent Posts from Towleroad

  • Older Gay Men Look Back at Stonewall: WATCH
    We’ve watched them try to interpret young gay slang, react to Troye Sivan videos, play Card Against Humanity, try to identify famous gays, play Never Have I Ever, identify pop star divas, respond to new song lyrics, clap back at mean comments, and remember past loves. Now Robert E. Reeves, Michael Peterson, Jessay Martin, and Bill Lyons take […] The post Old […]
  • Special Prosecutor Appointed to Investigate Why Charges Were Dropped in Jussie Smollett Case
    Cook county judge Michael Toomin appointed a special prosecutor on Friday to investigate why charges were dropped in the Jussie Smollett case. Smollett was indicted on 16 felony counts of disorderly conduct on March 6 for falsifying reports that he was the victim of a hate crime. Those charges were abruptly dropped on March 26 […] The post Special Prosecutor […]
  • Sen. Kamala Harris Introduces Bill That Would Make PrEP Free for Most Americans
    Senator and presidential hopeful Kamala Harris (D-CA) this week introduced legislation that would make pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) free for most patients. CNN reports: “Some insurance plans cover the drug. But even as more private insurance plans will cover the drug, Medicare and Medicaid are not required to add the benefit, according to the bill and […] […]
  • Florida Woman Speaks Out After Being Ordered to Take Down Her LGBTQ Pride Flag: WATCH
    Robin Chipman, a resident of the Waterside at Coquina Key condominium association (FB), (Twitter) in St. Petersburg, Florida, has been ordered to remove her LGBTQ Pride flag because some neighbor doesn’t like it, so she is speaking out to local news outlets. Said Chipman to WFLA: “I have friends and neighbors that are in the […] The post Florida Woman Speaks […]
  • Lawrence O’Donnell Speaks with E. Jean Carroll, Who Says Trump Raped Her: WATCH
    The Last Word‘s Lawrence O’Donnell spoke with E. Jean Carroll, who accused Donald Trump of raping her in a Bergdorf Goodman department store dressing room 23 years ago, in an article for New York magazine. Carroll said Trump coerced her into entering the dressing room with her, violently lunged at her, and sexually assaulted her […] The post Lawrence O’Donne […]

Polls

RSS Breaking News from The Daily Beast

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Pics from Africa 2010

About Me

https://rsiasoco.wordpress.com/about/

About Me

Ricco Villanueva Siasoco is a Manhattan-based writer and non-profit manager. More

Top Clicks

  • None

Categories